1,886,434 Ways the Long Tail Beat Klout

Linkedin Google+ Facebook Twitter StumbleUpon Email

Last Wednesday’s Give to the Max Day: Greater Washington netted $2,034,434, including 17,838 donations totaling $1,886,434. The online giving contest benefited 1200 nonprofits. As the general manager of the event, this kind of impact makes me profoundly grateful, and many thanks have already been sent to the donors, nonprofits and partners involved. Give to the Max Day also provided yet another example of how big social media names don’t necessarily translate into great social performance.

On the contrary, the majority of winners in Give to the Max Day Grand Awards were not the big nonprofit brands with sizable influencers locally. It was the little guys, the Little Lights Urban Ministries (Klout Score: 10) and For Love of Children, Inc. (Klout Score: 37) that won most donors and most donations, respectively.

If people were betting on popular nonprofit brands and influencers with big Klout scores to win the day, they would have lost a lot of money. While some participated and performed well, they didn’t take the grand prizes. In the end it was the long tail of small voices that drove the event’s leaderboards, and overall donation flow.

That’s not to say that big brands and influencers can’t succeed. As revealed in the PayPal Research paper, Effectiveness of Celebrity Spokespeople in Social Fundraisers, the secret formula for success in social media is not the most “influence” or size of account, rather it is engaged community, authenticity and a willingness to work. Any online brand can demonstrate that kind of investment and energy.

Frank Warren Book Signing

Two award winners were big influencers, and showed that kind of passion. The first was PostSecret‘s Frank Warren (Klout Score: 69), who won the Care2 Individual Fundraiser Award with his IMAlive fundraiser, which in turn triggered a third place finish for Most Donors for the Kristin Brooks Hope Center. Frank was very engaged in the weeks leading up to the event, asking questions about how to do well. Further, he is authentically passionate about this cause with a long history of fundraising and personal reasons to be engaged.

The second influential example is the fine performance of the Trustees of the Corcoran Gallery of Art. Though you couldn’t necessarily tell by a Klout Score of 49, the Corcoran is one of Washington’s premier institutions in the Arts Community. The Corcoran went all out with its ArtReach campaign, using a matching grant, emails and social media to invigorate its core. The result? A total of 438 donors and $55,189 in donations, good enough for third place in most dollars raised, and fourth place for most donors.

In the end, it’s not Klout or some other social media ranking that creates a success. It’s the passion and drive of the voices behind the effort.

Congratulations to all of the nonprofits who experimented, and learned more about online fundraising this past Wednesday (and the months leading up to it). Give to the Max Day: Greater Washington was a fun contest, and it’s an enjoyable exercise to break down what made a winning campaign. But the real winners in this day were you, the almost 18,000 citizens who supported you, and the region as a whole.

Linkedin Google+ Facebook Twitter StumbleUpon Email
  • http://twitter.com/CyberlandGal Monica

    Thanks for writing this post, Geoff. I am shocked to learning “Little Lights” Only has a Klout score of 10. The group really did an amazing job. What a great example of your secret formula for success in social media: an engaged community, authenticity and a willingness to work. 

    • http://twitter.com/geoffliving Geoff Livingston

      Thanks, Monica.  It was a great event, and we are all very thrilled with the results!

      • http://twitter.com/CyberlandGal Monica

        Congrats on a great job! I suspect the training you tweeted about also played a big role in empowering organizations with little “Klout” to harness their passion in a big way.

  • http://www.i95dev.com Henry Louis

    It is interesting to read this post. Thanks for sharing.

A New Novel from Geoff Livingston

Want news and an advanced copy of the book?
Your info is never shared

Work with My Company

Tenacity5 Media Logo

Buy Exodus for Just $0.99

You can buy the book from these vendors, including $0.99 on the Kindle store.

101 Things, a Bucket List

Pacific Sunset

Posts on Other Blogs

Vocus Marketing Blog
(2012-present)

Inspiring Generosity
(2011-2012)

Mashable
(2009-2011)

The Buzz Bin
(2006-2010)

Archives

Categories

My Photos

Zinnia Row by Geoff Livingston
Rose Row by Geoff Livingston
A Delicate Weed by Geoff Livingston
The Devil's Horns Re-Edit by Geoff Livingston
Green, Blue and Red in the Fog by Geoff Livingston
Foggy Morning by Geoff Livingston
Yellow Zinnia by Geoff Livingston
The Wonder of the Skies by Geoff Livingston
Heron on the Edge by Geoff Livingston
Ford Model A by Geoff Livingston
The Henry Ford Museum by Geoff Livingston